Let's see Aaron's game from yesterday against Katherine as he clearly struggles with temptation. Black is to move in the next three positions. Answers are at the end, or will be by tomorrow.
5. In this continuation of the above game, white just played 18. Nf4. Aside from moving the bishop, which rook moves protect against losing a piece?
6. Kirk played 11...Re8 in this position against former 318 player Maya McGreen. Why is it bad?
7. Mikael just played 4...Bf5 as black. How should he have been punished?
8. Nasir is black in the above position. Which move is better, 5...h5 or 5...h6?
9. Nasir just played 10...Nbd7. What happened next?
|top 6th grader, Nancy Wang|
|Markus Pond, top 8th grader??|
|Mengnan Chen, 6th grade 1350|
tilt your screen way back and look at the door handle
|top 7th grader Tristan Dalhouse|
|706 friends: Michael Yu and Stefek Yurgel|
1. Black should not trade queens, because that just repairs white's pawn structure and gives him the open a file. Instead, black could play 1...Nc6 or 1...Rc8 2. Qxb6? Nxb6. White should not trade queens because it just develops black's knight towards its outpost on c4.
2. Black has a number of reasonable moves, including
* 14...a5!, planning ...b5, ...a4, making a passed pawn
* 14...h5! preventing g2-g4 and securing the f5 square for the knight
* 14... f6!, trading off white's good central pawn, and getting black some space (i.e. 15. exf6 gxf6 and 16...Rg8)
* 14...Nb6 defending d5 in case of c3-c4xd5.
But the trade 14...Nxe3 is not good: the knight is better than the bishop in this closed position, it opens the f file for white; d4 is now defended. But it is also a mistake because black can make this trade any time he wants to, so he should keep the tension and wait for a more favorable moment.
3. 16...Nb6 makes more sense than 16...dxe4, since the first move develops our knight and the second one develops white's. Houdini doesn't agree with me, it thinks they are about equal, but I think from a teaching standpoint I'm right.
4. Four reasonable ideas for black:
12...Nb4 13. Qg3 Rc8
12...Nd5 to exchange some pieces 13. Bxd5 (13. Nxd5?? exd5 -/+; 13. Bxe7 Ncxe7) 13...Bxg5
12...h6 why not
Lennin played 12...Qc7, which is not a great square for the queen because it gives up control of d5 and the queen can be attacked with Bf4, Rc1 or Nb5/d5.
5. Moves like 18...Rfd8 obviously defend the bishop. 18...Rac8 works in a slightly trickier way, 19. Nxd5 Qxd5 20. Qxd5 Nxd5 21. Rxc8 Rxc8 22. Rxd5 Rc1+. But even 18...Rfe8 defends the bishop, since 19. Nxd5 Nxd5 20. Qxd5 Re1! wins!
6. 11...Re8 loses the d5 pawn to 12. Bxd5 exd5 13. Rxe8 Qxe8 15. Nxd5
7. White could have won a pawn with Ob3, attacking f7 and b7.
8. 5...h5 is much better, but kids get confused with the advanced variation, where h5 is hard to hold, so ...h6 is better. Black got punished in this game after 5...h6 6. h5 Bh7 7. e6 fxe6 8. Bd3 Bxd3 9. Qxd3 Nf6 9. Nc3 Nbd7 (next diagram)
9. 10. Qg6#!